Most people know Edgar Allan Poe by his poem “The Raven” or even some of his short stories such as the “Tell-Tale Heart” or “The Masque of the Red Death.” My own obsession with Poe began in middle school after I had read “The Pit and the Pendulum.” My grandma kept a collection of his books in her house that I read deep into the night, drowning out my brother’s snores.
While these stories describe a mysterious, creepy, and at times, murderous personality, the actual character of Edgar Allan Poe has been much evaded. It has been hard to grasp the kind of person he was, even to historians, as there have been much speculation to both his life and death. This article will be discussing the facts (and fiction) of the mysterious man, while also taking a closer look at his death, which remains a mystery even today.
Sad Beginnings
What is known about Poe is that his life was almost as depressing as his stories. According to the biography by The Poe Museum, Poe’s parents were traveling actors and were in Boston when Poe was born on January 19, 1809. His father, David Poe Jr. left his mother, Eliza Poe, shortly after Poe was born. Eliza died only three years after.
There have been speculation, according to 10 Mind-Blowing Facts about Edgar Allan Poe by Matthew Childers, as to whether or not Poe had been named after the character Edgar in the play King Lear by Shakespeare, as both of his parents participated in the play when he was born. Other sources, such as Why Edgar Allan Poe’s Death Remains a Mystery by Jordan Zakarin, explain that Poe’s foster father, John Allan, gave him the name. Nonetheless, things supposedly began looking up for Poe after he was brought in to live with the wealthy tobacco merchant and his wife, Francis in Richmond, Virginia.
Growing Up
John Allan, having no children of his own, had taken young Poe as his son and heir. Allan planned on giving Poe all of the education and wealth needed to continue in his business, giving him a long, wealthy, and prosperous life.
Those plans were basically eradicated by the time Poe learned how to write. On the backs of some his ledger sheets, he wrote unfinished stories and poems from a young age, aspiring to be his favorite writer, Lord Byron, a British Poet (The Poe Museum). Poe showed no interest in becoming a businessman, much to the disappointment of his foster father.
Even so, Poe still attended the University of Virginia in 1826. Most sources say that while he was marvelous in his classes, he produced a gambling debt. In reference to 10 Mind-Blowing Facts About Edgar Allan Poe, John Allan would give Poe money under the assumption that Poe needed more to pay for his classes, when reality Poe was trying to pay off debt. However, according to the biography by The Poe Museum, Allan sent a third of the money that Poe needed to pay for classes, so Poe took up gambling. Either way, Poe amassed a gambling debt he was unable to get out of, causing him to drop out of the university.
With his head hung low, he returned home, only to find that his fiancée, Elmira Royster, was engaged to another. These series of events squeezed the tension of Poe’s relationship with his foster father even further, until finally, Poe moved out to be on his own. He was accepted into the military at West Point, while still trying to work on his poetry and short story writing. He was thrown out of the program only after eight months.
Poe’s Careers and Marriage(s)
The long list of Edgar Allan Poe’s series of life events that happened after West Point become confusing. According to 13 Haunting Facts about Edgar Allan Poe’s Death by Christopher P. Semtner, after Poe was kicked out of West Point, he became the editor at the Southern Literary Messenger in Richmond. The Messenger became more popular with Poe’s fiction and book reviews in just seventeen months. The source explains he was fired twice (reasons unknown), and after the second time, he took many other editorial positions in New York and Philadelphia, while also speaking in lectures and public readings.
But The Poe Museum explains that after Poe left West Point, he moved in with his aunt Maria Clemm. While there, he became close with his cousin, Virginia. Meanwhile, Poe’s foster father passed away, leaving Poe out of his will. Instead John Allan left everything to an illegitimate child Poe had never even met.
Poe was living in poverty, and in no doubt needed money. He started publishing more of his short stories, winning him a contest run by the Saturday Visitor. This gave Poe writing fuel to publish more stories and to acquire a job at the Southern Literary Messenger in Richmond.
The source also explains how Poe made the Messenger one of the most popular literary magazines in the south with his writing and book reviews. This is where his rivalry began with Rufus Griswold.
When he was twenty-seven, Poe married Virginia, who was only thirteen years old at the time. Poe still did not make enough money. Whether or not he actually was fired from the Messenger or he left, he still moved to New York City to pursue more editorial jobs.
While married and still unable to make a living, Poe wrote the most popular poem (arguably) in the world, “The Raven” which was published in January 1845. The poem would make him nearly famous overnight, but he was only paid about fifteen dollars for the publication.
According to The Poe Museum, the publication of “The Raven” drew more crowds to his lectures and his public readings. Because of it’s fame, Poe began demanding better pay for his work and he continued on to publish two more books that same year.
While things seemed to be looking up for Poe, in 1846, disaster struck. Virginia’s health began to go down hill, and fast. Poe moved out of New York City and to a cottage in the country. In 1847, his wife, Virginia, died of tuberculosis at the age of twenty-four. It was said that her death devastated Poe so much, he could not write anything for months.
In the summer of 1849, Poe moved back to Richmond, Virginia. There, he once again met his first fiancée, Elmira Royster, who was now a widow. Their love sparked once again, and not too long after, they became engaged.
Unfortunately, Poe would not live to see his wedding day.
Poe’s Mysterious Death
There are five days in which Poe was missing. No one heard from him nor knew where he was. According to 13 Haunting Facts about Edgar Allan Poe’s Death, one of the last letters Poe ever wrote was to a Mrs. St. Leon. In the letter, they set up a meeting in Philadelphia so that Poe could edit a book of her poetry. He left for Philadelphia in October of 1849.
A week before his trip to Philadelphia, Poe went to see his doctor friend, John carter. Elmira Shelton was concerned for his health and said that he appeared ill to her. Carter advised Poe to stay in Richmond a couple of more days before going on his trip. When he left Carter’s house, Poe accidentally took Carter’s sword cane instead of his own.
Most sources say he went as far as Baltimore before disappearing. On October 3rd, five or so days after his departure, he was seen outside of the bar, Gunner’s Hall, confused, delirious, wearing clothes that did not fit him, and having no luggage. Later, one trunk of his luggage would be found in Baltimore, the other in Richmond.
Outside of Gunner’s Hall, Poe was recognized by a man named Joseph Walker. He asked Poe if he could contact anyone for him. Poe told him to write a letter to an editor named Joseph Snodgrass. According to Why Edgar Allan Poe’s Death Remains A Mystery, the letter said:
“Dear Sir,
There is a gentlemen, rather worse for wear, at Ryan’s 4th ward polls, who goes under the cognomen of Edgar A. Poe, and who appears in grand distress, and he says he is acquainted with you, he is in need of immediate assistance.
Yours, in haste,
JOS. W. WALKER
To Dr. J.E. Snodgrass”
Poe was then taken to Washington College Hospital. At this point, there is much speculation as to what happened, for both doctors and historians. Poe was put in a windowless room and saw only Dr. John Moran. Poe then died on October 7th, 1849.
There are no records of his hospital stay before his death. There was no autopsy done, as the cause of death was put to be “congestion of the brain.” This saying could mean the doctors who looked after Poe believed he died of a drug or alcohol overdose.
In reference to 13 Haunting Facts about Edgar Allan Poe’s Death, Moran wrote articles and a book called Edgar Allan Poe: A Defense, in order to defuse the rumors that Poe had died of an overdose. Unfortunately, Moran’s writings and accounts of what happened vary, and are not considered reliable.
However, according to Why Edgar Allan Poe’s Death Remains A Mystery, Poe was not a heavy drinker. In fact, he was considered to be a light weight. There were rumors that he drank more when his wife, Virginia died. Not long after, he pledged sobriety and joined the Sons of Temperance a few months before his death. Joseph Snodgrass was passionate about the temperance movement and usually used Poe as an example of how drinking can be dangerous.
There are many theories on how Poe actually died. Some specialists believe that Poe may have had rabies, which would explain his deliriousness and confusion. A researcher and professor at the University of Maryland Medical Center, Dr. R Michale Benitez researched this theory and gained national attention at a medical conference in 1996. According to the accounts of Dr. Moran, Poe became feverish and had spikes of madness. He also, at times, had refused to drink water. Both could be a sign of rabies.
Other theories suggest the flu that turned into pneumonia, carbon monoxide poisoning, or heavy metal poisoning. Most of these theories have been rejected. There is one that seems more plausible than the rest, but it is hard to prove.
Edgar Allan Poe could have been a victim of “cooping.” This is a type of electoral fraud in which people were kidnapped off the street, drugged, and then forced to participate in the voting polls over and over again. Eventually, the victim would be let go, but the drugs in their system would cause them to die. Gunner’s Hall, the tavern that Poe was found outside of, was next to a voting place. This could explain Poe’s deliriousness, madness, and even the fact he wasn’t even wearing his own clothes when he was found.
After Death
An obituary for Edgar Allan Poe was published by a person named Ludwig. This obituary painted the picture that Poe was a horrible human being, obsessed with greed, drugs, alcohol, and women. The only good thing the obituary mentioned was Poe’s writing skill, but even his statue as a human being was diminished.
“Still though, he regarded society as composed of villains, the sharpness of his intellect was not of that kind which enabled him to cope with villainy, while it continually caused him overshots, to fail at the success of honesty.” (Death of Edgar Allan Poe)
Some strange happenings occurred even after Edgar Allan Poe died. According to 13 Haunting Facts about Edgar Allan Poe’s Death, some of these events including his cat abruptly dying, people taking Poe’s hair while visiting his body (including Joseph Snodgrass), and various accounts of people seeing Poe after he had died.
The more creepier events happened decades after Poe’s death. Edgar Allan Poe was buried in an unmarked grave on the plot of his grandfather in Westminster Burying Grounds in Baltimore. Twenty-six years after the death of Poe, teachers and students raised enough money for an actual monument to be placed next to the cemetery gate. While the coffin was being moved, the bottom fell out, exposing Poe’s remains. Some of the pieces of the coffin became a collector’s item.
Virginia, Poe’s wife who died of tuberculosis, was originally buried in Poe’s landlord’s crypt in the Bronx. After Poe had been moved to the new location, admirers of Poe suggested Virginia be moved next to him. Some developers had built over her cemetery and moved her body. One of Poe’s biographers, William Gill, had rescued her bones. He had kept Virginia’s remains under his bed for years before the admirers of Poe suggested the move.
Closing Thoughts
While Edgar Allan Poe lived a sad life, most of his work is still known far and wide, even today. He is known for creating the detective fiction genre with the character C. Auguste Dupin, who appeared in “The Murders in the Rue Morgue.” The character became the inspiration to create others like Sherlock Holmes and Agatha Christie. He is also known as one of the first authors to demand a higher wage and income while publishing his stories.
While there may be a lot of speculation about Edgar Allan Poe’s life and death, no one can argue that Poe was one of the most genius and memorable writers in history.